A bright ray of hope shone on the breakfast table while visiting friends this morning.
Two weeks ago I reviewed Sugar Coated, Unboxing the Hidden Forces Shaping America’s Favorite Breakfast Food, Marion Nestle and Lisa Sutherland’s new telling of the transformation of a 19th century health food, un-sugared granola, into a keystone of the American ultraprocessed food diet. The Kellogg brothers’ of the 1870s, launched as disciples into the American food environment by the fervently health-preaching Seventh-day Adventist church, started a lineage that one-hundred years later resulted in the bastardized, unholy, unhealthy Kellogg’s Froot Loops of 1963 with its 12 grams of added sugar, bright artificial colors, refined flours, and child-targeting Toucan Sam mascot.
Today’s food environment: gone to hell in a shopping cart
Since 1963 it’s been sixty years of the American food environment generally going to hell in a shopping cart, but, praise be to Nestle and Sutherland, the first a deity in matters of nutrition policy, the descent into ultraprocessed Hades turns out to be a two-way path!
Uncommonly intutive pre-schoolers
My friends, let’s call them Pop and Mima just as their three- and five-year-old grandchildren do, made a point of eating healthy breakfasts every day. But Pop and Mima first and foremost, love their grandkids and understand the license that grandparents have in making sure the adoring love of the little ones pours back in return. So Froot Loops were acquired for the first morning of a four-day stay of the preschoolers with Pop and Mima. On the morning of the first day, Pop poured himself a bowl of granola, while Mima got ready to pour two bowls of Froot Loops for the little ones. Lo and behold, at Pop’s first bite, adoring Child 1 said “I want what Pop is having” and adoring Child 2 said “Me, too!” And granola, with yogurt, fruit, and a little drizzle of maple syrup to seal the deal, is all the four of them ate every day for breakfast. Pop and Mima, your medal is in the mail.
Pop and Mima deserve a medal
In my experience as a parent there is little precedent for Pop and Mima’s granola magic. It was a breakfast miracle. There is hope.
The coffee pot
Today it’s Breakfast in America on Eating in America, or at least, perhaps, Part One, since, as you will see, I don’t get far on the breakfast menu. We’re going to start where many of us start our day: at the coffee pot.
And a lot of Americans drink coffee: ¾ of us. Half of us drink it every day. 1 And mostly in the morning. For some people, breakfast is only coffee.
It is not my fault or your fault
These days as the writer of Eating In America, I feel like I’m the bearer of bad news far too much. It’s not really my fault: I am not a wellness influencer peddling hope in exchange for clicks, and neither you nor I are responsible for screwing up the food environment. We’re both just figuring out how to do the best for ourselves and our families with the food we are dealt. And, when I write about the politics and the commercial side of our food environment, it’s about who we can blame, boycott, or vote against, all of which feels better and is far more accurate than blaming ourselves.
Coffee: the dependable feel good nutrition story
But when I write about coffee and tea, it’s a happy, feel good story, with the science continuing to tell us that these beverages that most of us enjoy and that make us feel good, are, in fact, good for us.
And the science keeps coming.
A study of healthy aging and coffee in women was presented at the American Society of Nutrition conference last year. 2 It was the offshoot of a larger study based on data from 47,000 nurses. Given all the attention the coffee study has received, it’s surprising it’s not been published as a peer-reviewed paper. The researchers found a small boost in the odds of healthy aging for women who drink coffee. For every cup of caffeinated coffee consumed, the odds of healthy aging increased 5%. If you’re doing the math to check on what you drink, it’s not a straight line increase, it’s exponential. So from 5% for one cup daily, it goes to about 16% increased chance of healthy aging for three cups. Probably not enough to warrant taking up the drinking of coffee or tea.
Coffee’s good, but the Nurses study’s story on cola? A whole other thing…
What didn’t get the attention of the media from the Nurses study is that, on average, for each 12 ounce cola, like Coca-Cola, the women drank daily, they had 19% reduced odds of healthy aging and up to 26% odds of a major chronic disease, a physical function limitation, a mental health or cognitive impairment, or a memory complaint. The exponential math says drinking three cans of cola per day is associated with a 47% reduction in the odds of healthy aging.
Neither thumbs up nor thumbs down for tea and decaf coffee
Please note that this type of study finds associations, not causes, so we can’t at all say that colas caused the reduced chance of healthy aging or coffee increased the chance. I should add that the Nurses study found no difference in healthy aging outcomes associated with drinking tea or decaf coffee.
Good news for Finnish men who drink more coffee than anybody in the world (and for coffee drinking men in general)
Then there’s a new study of very old data, collected in Finland in 1966, which came out in July.3 It found that in men with the same BMI, or Body Mass Index, higher coffee consumption was associated with more muscle mass and less fat tissue, always a good thing.
Estradiol and caffeine, and caffeine related to reduced risk for a number of diseases
There are differences in the effects of caffeine in women and men, attributable to hormones like estradiol, which slows down the metabolism of caffeine in women. 4 But there is a long list of studies finding associations for both men and women between coffee and reduced mortality, diabetes, Parkinson disease, depression, and cancer.
Earlier I wrote that half of us drink coffee every day and about ¾ of us drink it during a given year. This was determined by scientists of the National Cancer Institute who analyzed national health surveys from 2003 to 2006 and published their findings in 2016. The data may seem a little old, but I checked their findings against several other surveys, and found that coffee consumption has been remarkably stable in the U.S. in the 21st century, both overall and across age groups.
There are two aspects I find remarkable. First is that coffee consumption has been steady by age group.
Alcohol consumption goes high in the twenties
With another commonly consumed substance, alcohol, the age 18 to 29 group seems to jump at the chance to drink on reaching adulthood.5 That group drinks at least occasionally at about the same rate as the age 30 to 49 group, a little over 70%. Then the decline in alcohol consumption begins. The age 50 to 64 group drinks at least occasionally at a rate a little under 70%. The falloff becomes much steeper in the age 65 and up group, which drinks at least occasionally at a rate around 55%.
Coffee consumption is restrained in the twenties
By contrast, youths do not give the statistical impression they can’t wait to begin drinking coffee when they reach adulthood. I wonder if coffee was forbidden for under 21s, and Starbucks carded everyone trying to purchase a latte, sales of coffee to 21-year-olds who had just reached legal coffee age, would zoom. “Heh, I’m 21 today. You want to see my license? I’ll have a triple espresso, neat.”
Of course, the area where regulation of caffeine to teens and others should be considered is in colas. The sweeteners in colas are harmful to health and the addition of caffeine into the diet of a teenager or younger child is, I’m sorry, just gratuitous. Oh, for the boundless energy and metabolism of a teenager again. Although perhaps the appearance of continuous boundless energy only comes if the diet is healthy. I have to make a note to investigate whether there is any evidence that caffeinated drinks are sold to and used by kids to help them recover when they crash off a sugar high.
Further, the sales of caffeinated energy drinks and shots which can be used by youths in conjunction with alcohol can be unsafe by encouraging hyped-up over-consumption and risk taking.
Coffee drinking numbers grow steadily, and a lot, by age group
As it is, the coffee drinking population grows steadily with age. In rough numbers, adults in their twenties take the occasional coffee at a rate of 60%. The thirty-plus group sips at a 70% rate. From there it is about a 5% increase each decade. Those in their forties take coffee at a rate of 75%, fifties at 80%, and those in their sixties and older are hardcore coffee drinkers at a rate of over 85%.
And this pattern holds over time. The over-60 group that drinks coffee at a rate over 85% drank coffee at rate of about 60% when they were in their twenties, the same as those in their twenties today.
Is the addictiveness of coffee indicated by the growth in numbers over aging?
The very strong growth in coffee drinking numbers across decades is consistent with the addictive quality of coffee, but the slowness of the growth raises the question as to whether there is some weakness in the quality of that addictiveness. If you, like me, feel strongly addicted to coffee, you might think that is a silly question.
Here is a possibility. Since caffeine is the component in coffee that is actively addictive, could it be that when you add in cola consumption the younger groups are taking as much caffeine as the older groups and so are just as addicted, when only caffeine is looked at?
Cola caffeine consumption starts early but it is coffee that is the big source, and younger people still consume less caffeine than older groups
The answer seems to be “no.” One study of overall caffeine consumption in the U.S. indicates that those in their 20s are not consuming nearly as much caffeine as those in the 30 to 49 year old group.6 Both groups drink on average across the group about one cola per day and ½ cup of dark tea or one cup of green tea, but the older group drinks about twice as much coffee.
There is a lifelong coffee plateau at an average of two cups at age 30
So there is this real trend for more people to drink coffee as they age, but, interestingly, the amount of coffee per day holds fairly steady past the age of 30 at about two cups, with a little bump up to 2-1/4 cups per day in the age 50 to 59 group and then back down to two cups for those 60 and up. So more people drink coffee as they age, but once about 2 cups on average is reached, the amount of coffee consumed per coffee drinker stays basically the same.
Not strongly addictive but not many people trying to quit?
The other thing that surprised me is that about ¾ of adult Americans drink coffee at some point during the year, but only half of adults drink it every day. Apparently, unlike some very-bad-for-you addictive substances, like the opioids, the pull towards addiction is not that strong. But clearly, once addicted, given the instant and long-term hidden benefits of coffee, the pull to give it up is not strong at all.
But there is usually more to breakfast than coffee. Let us know your favorite breakfast beverage rituals and, I would love to hear about your favorite breakfast memory, either around a tradition in your house or maybe a surprise when you traveled.
Thank you for reading, and thank you for your comments, stories, likes and shares, all of which support Eating In America, as do your subscriptions.
References
Loftfield E, Freedman ND, Dodd KW, et al. Coffee Drinking Is Widespread in the United States, but Usual Intake Varies by Key Demographic and Lifestyle Factors. J Nutr. Sep 2016;146(9):1762–8. doi:https://doi.org/10.3945/jn.116.233940
Mahdavi S, Hu F, Sun Q, Willett W, Ardisson Korat AV. Caffeine Intake and Healthy Aging in Women. Current Developments in Nutrition. 2025;9doi:https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cdnut.2025.106062
Verroest L, Jokelainen J, Choudhary S, et al. Associations of habitual coffee intake with testosterone and cardiometabolic markers: the Northern Finland birth cohort 1966 study. European Journal of Nutrition. 2026/07/16 2026;65(5):215. doi:https://doi.org/10.1007/s00394-026-04038-z
Temple JL, Ziegler AM. Gender Differences in Subjective and Physiological Responses to Caffeine and the Role of Steroid Hormones. J Caffeine Res. Mar 2011;1(1):41–48. doi:https://doi.org/10.1089/jcr.2011.0005
Ayyala-Somayajula D, Dodge JL, Lee BP. Alcohol Use Between 2018 and 2024: A National Cross-Sectional Study. Ann Intern Med. 2026;doi:https://doi.org/10.7326/ANNALS-26-01824
Drewnowski A, Rehm CD. Sources of Caffeine in Diets of US Children and Adults: Trends by Beverage Type and Purchase Location. Nutrients. 2016;8(3):154. doi:https://doi.org/10.3390/nu8030154









